Jump to content

Element Manta Strobe


LightningLion

Recommended Posts

Kinda disappointed that they put "E-Lite" on it

I'm normally a real stickler for accurate trademarks, but I'm kinda glad they did this. I'd be worried this got in the hands of troops who depend their lives on their equipment and for it to fail on them. At least with E-Lite on it, the replica will pass a cursory inspection but still clearly not 100% authentic.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I would buy this sort of stuff because at the end of the day, I'm playing with toys. I don't really need to worry about things not working when I need them. Sure it's annoying if they don't work, but it's no big deal. If my life was on the line, I would stump up the extra £ for the real deal. Surely people don't buy this sort of stuff to rely on in real world scenarios? Also, might it compromise insurance stuff? Anyway, the authentic stuff is more expensive for a reason, better QC, materials etc. Surely not worth the risk.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...

I saw that at JK Army the other day, they're calling it FMA brand instead of Element. The same photo (with less blur) is shown elsewhere as the Element prototype Manta strobe.

 

Is FMA an OEM for Element, or some kind of rebrand? Replica V-lites (E-lites) are sold under both names with different photos, prices, and packaging:

 

 

G FMA Velcro "Safty" Lite:

 

http://www.ebairsoft.com/velcro-safty-lite-class-p-5189.html

http://www.jkarmy.com/eng/magento/fma-velcro-safty-lite-class-a.html

 

 

G Element EX234 E-LITE:

 

http://www.ebairsoft.com/element-ex234-elite-velcro-safety-light-p-5306.html

http://www.jkarmy.com/eng/magento/element-ex234-e-lite-coming-soon.html

 

Judging by the photos, perhaps the FMA brand was created to sell the same product with undisguised trades.

Link to post
Share on other sites

To aclarate it: FMA seems to be a different brand. With correct marking (V-Lite instead of E-Lite) and correct size. At least I´ve heard that Element E-Lite are not 100% accurate with the size of the S&S original ones. At least is what I asume, specially considering this:

In JKArmy you can pre-order the FMA Manta Strobe with horrible transparent plastic:

http://www.jkarmy.com/eng/magento/fma-devil-rays-strobe-velcro-safety-lite-ir-green-led-pre-order.html

 

A Chinese copy of a chinese copy?

 

Also, final version of Element Manta Strobe will come with a "blurred" plastic instead of that horrible transparente one.

You can see more about actual version of Element Manta Strobe on my new blog´s post.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The photo at JK ARMY (FMA) is the same one on your blog (ELEMENT), just blurrier. And the original prototype pics from Element were the ones with the too-clear housing.

 

So is FMA is cloning the clone (and borrowing pre-production photos), or releasing more accurate copies under a throwaway brand to protect Element from litigation?

 

Anyways, this afternoon I should have some Element and FMA V-lites in hand; unfortunately I don't have any real ones handy but I can at least do a comparison between the two fakes.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...

After playing using both the E-Lite and the V-Lite, the V-Lite is a lot brighter than the E-Lite. Side by side, you cannot tell the difference (except for the E-Lite branded into the plastic).

For Airsofters looking for that "Look", and for 15.00 - it is a good buy.

If you want to spend 40 to 50 and want the real deal, you have that option as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

The FMA Manta strobe is up for sale, at first glance it looks somewhat better than the Element prototype photos: http://www.ebairsoft.com/snail-strobe-light-green-p-5456.html

 

It seems like S&S had a couple different versions of the knob and FMA cloned the newer low profile version. If it's anything like their clone V-lite, I wouldn't trust the Velcro adhesive to stay put.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and the use of session cookies.