Jump to content


Photo
* * * * - 5 votes

Blog: Magpul PTS announces the PDR AEG

Magpul PTS SHOT Show 2012 PDR AEG

  • Please log in to reply
431 replies to this topic

#121 intinerious

intinerious

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 908 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 05:03 AM

GRR! Damn you all for making me look like a ARES marketing rep...

Well, i must admit in Cost vs Performance ARES might fail but considoring i can get PTW-grade performance out of a Cheapo ACM gun with few tweaks dont that mean everything above that said ACM-cheapo is not very cost-efficant?

Like i said i dont wanna sound like an ARES-fanboy but instead to prove its no worse then most brands out there. Hmm... That said, what would it need to be "equal" in your eyes? Pump out massive FPS? Huge ROF? Both? Its been quite some time since i took mine apart so i cant recall all details so clearly but trying to think back i see no problems fitting most parts to say, my AK74U or fitting the parts from the AK to the TAR21... Out of the two i'd say ARES takes a small lead over the Dboys AK. Dunno if i'd put my money on a fancy Systema Probox over ARES TAR21 gearbox(as in internals, not just shell), be it a brutal stress-test "till the end" or typical skirmishing.
If i recall, wasn it so that a regular piston needed modification to fit the TAR21? Cant remember that on mine. Ok. Lets say its so, or any part for that matter. They made a TAR21, freaking sweet! Even has nifty features like spring-release and quick-change, i'd forgive them a few "may need some modding" -bits for all they have done.

Heres a question. What does other guns have that the TAR21 cannot have due to its "special TAR21-only parts" ? Considoring it is an assault-rifle.
Jeah im sure someone is really sad somewhere cause his didnt work as a SAW and sniper at the same time and now hates ARES for it while sleeping next to his 249 with biiiig scope on it.

Reminds me of me and guy next door. I buy a new Mercedes-Benz with a big engine, he buys a Toyota that runs on batteries or so. Both cars get the job done, he for some reason just seems to hate anything with a Merc-star on it for some reason and spreads the hate all over... Does that make mine bad? Im also fairly sure Prius doesnt have a "sport" model regardless if the tags he has on his boot ^^

I believe both the guy next door and someone not using a TAR21 as an assault-rifle is an idiot.


LOL it's fine that you like ARES and all, and I've never owned one myself, but have a friend at owns one and understand that it's a pain to fix (even in Hong Kong where you'd expect to be able to find parts...being ARES is based in HK and all) and as I frequent ASM I'll take what I read about ARES and stay far away from it. Their price tag is sure the disincentive to get an ARES if they really have issues and have inflexibility in upgrading for me!

What's with the comparison with the elcheapo-ACM guns? I think you mean it should be said that ACM guns are the MOST cost effective? In that case it would be a resounding 'yes', but remember those who CAN tune an ACM gun up to crazy levels aren't your average tech, so they might not have the knowledge to let them do DSG builds and such, meaning that the cost v performance comparative would be lower compared to other brands just because they cannot reach the same level of teching as some people do. There's also the factor of the external appearance. For function over form, some ACM guns really beat the rest (like the Golden Eagle or JG G36...if you've seen the new batch, you wouldn't think it's elcheapo ACM XD) but like you said and you're trying to put forward; there's a lot of ACM brands out there that have much lower quality and specs than ARES or even OTHER guns that are in the ACM 'grouped brand' that we're talking about, so don't let us ACM brand supporters for the cost v performance part trick you into thinking we support ALL the makes of ACM :P

For ARES to be equal, they should either start by lowering their price and use non-proprietary stuff. There's nothing wrong with the current standard trigger contacts, and they play along nicely with FETs if it's required, but if you've frequent ASM enough you'll find that their trigger switches aren't friendly to FETs at all and they do have a tendency to break...and then getting replacement parts are a PITA, etc. :P

Also, they don't have to churn out high ROF and FPS out of the box! No OOTB gun do that anyway! :P It's the ABILITY for ARES AEGs to be able to be modified to the same level as their other competitor's AEGs with the same amount of hassle as modding the competitor's AEGs would make ARES attractive for me to buy. Their externals...for the plastics used, is probably on par with the quality of VFC products right? So if they can do what VFC does, which is quality externals and so-so internals, but the internals being non-proprietary stuff, and charging roughly the same amount as VFC does for their guns (maybe slightly less if the gun has a plastic receiver) then that would make ARES very attractive.

I think you're also putting a lot of emphasis on the fact that only ARES has made an acceptable TAR21 replica...that's true, and that's why everyone buys ARES if they can get their hands on one rather than get the S&T if they knew about the crappier materials S&T used (right S&T users? If I'm wrong lemme know :P). But the fact is for those that are comparing AEG to AEG, not TAR21 to TAR21, ARES lose out big time.

And those bits of 'destructive' modding to get regular parts to work on the ARES is probably the same reason why some of us hate KWA as well XD The amount of mods required for both to fit TM specced parts (if available) is probably the same.

And your comparison of us with your neighbour doesn't work. We aren't jealous of your gun (and stop rubbing it in our faces that you have a Merc :P), we're just not accepting ARES for giving us a product that we want (like the TAR21) but with a huge price tag and the inflexibility of modding the gun :D If you come on the forums and say why you like ARES and you don't understand all the ARES hate, someone who doesn't like ARES is bound to pipe up with their reason as to why. We're not advocating you to follow our position, but rather that we both accept each other's reasons why we hate or love ARES and leave it at that :P Both aznriptide859 and myself understand your reasons why you like ARES, but it just seems like you don't understand why (or don't accept) both of us (and many others) for our dislike of ARES :P

this is turning ridiculous. 60rps? 3J? since when did airsoft turn into star trek laser beams? :D
In general you can buy all the parts you want for tune up, yes even with an Ares, just do research.
But If you don't have the skills to make em to good use, then it's rubbish. Regardless of the brand.

Besides most AEG's function improperly due to bad battery and bb's, or simply bad user.


Hey, if you can do it, like I said before, that means anything in between those ROF and power levels would be build-able! :D

So in general ARES can be counted as having aftermarket support, or are you saying that their stock parts in your experience are easy to get?

#122 steve ashworth

steve ashworth

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 111 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 11:29 AM

its different I will give it that, looks like the *bramston pickle* off spring of a P90 and an Aug :)
1 Squadron
Swift & Sudden

WTB - SCAR-L in Black

#123 swatti

swatti

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 307 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Classified
  • Country:Finland

Posted 27 July 2012 - 02:14 PM

I think i am starting to see why you guys dislike ARES and why i like it. Personaly i have nearly ten years of tuning guns under my belt, i dare say im very good at without bragging about it.

You guys want something "exotic" and new to be just like any other AK and AR15 out there, tech-wise. Very much understandable but often VERY hard if not impossible. Kinda like thinking race-cars were as simple as any 4-door sedan. My car reference was not to brag or about jealesy in any way. The "guy next door" bought a cheaper and very much more "cost efficant" car and for no reason turned into Merc-hater because its just different and has much more complex fancy toys and optional extras in it he says: "where do you even use those?".

Heres another example. ICS AR15. Mostly fits typical parts but has different threads in the upper-reciever then regular, plain stupid thing to do and makes swapping in a new front just a plain misery... Still, i do it and simply "forgive" the brand. I specificly wanted an ICS gun, even bought a second. Why? Cause i think the 2-piece gearbox is brilliant and i can test parts with it VERY fast.
I want something "different" and so "must" pay the price for it for being different.

I find it no problem to modify parts so they can fit and i do believe the modding needed in ARES guns were quite minor(?) but a lot of ppl dont want to mod their guns or dont know how to. That is perfectly understandable. In that case however, one should not expect to get past-the-limits-perfomance from a gun.
If you want a decent OOTB assault-rifle for the price-range that is "different" from the typical AK and AR15 models out there, i would gladly recommend a ARES TAR21. If you want to go past the typical limits of a typical AEG, then the ARES parts may cause issues. For an unusual exterior i think ppl should accept it may have unusual internals.
The only ones who seem to be "hating" it are ppl who for some reason want to go past the typical limit for no apperent reason. They are maybe less then 1% of the buyers/users as most will be very happy with their gun just as it is.

I stumbled upon the micro-switch hate that then turned into ARES-hate in ASM, im fairly sure i'd have micro-switch rather then "genital herpes" as mentioned once somewhere there. One of my friends came over soon after with his TAR21 (that i recommended to him and he loves) in hopes of getting mosfet fitted. We also have a CPU-mosfet that actually did have issues due to the micro-switch as described in ASM(yet i'd rather have those over "genital Herpes") as in vibrations from the shooting causes the fets open & close bazillion times more then they should...
Soooo, instead of resulting in hating and referring a working cost-efficant solution to genital-disease i took it "as a challenge" and went into a local electric-stuff-store and discribed the issue and what i needed. The clerk poked around the original part and took some measurements. Week later few possible working parts arrived and they cost about 5€ each, "shock / vibration proof" micro-switches as they were described. Supposedly used in boat-engines mostly, diesel-engines shake and vibrate. Also water-proof! ^^
Later we installed our CPU fet and went thru its logs. The problems caused by the original part were gone. My gun remains stock, my friends gun runs fine with the CPU-fet.

(Also there is a theory that such issues can be countered by not using a break-fet and increasing the resistor-size for the wake-up current of the normal-fet so it "cleans out" the vibration-static a bit. No personal experience, theory from an actual exprert in electronics and builder of our CPU-fet)

It would be A LOT better if ARES had the typical tm-style V3 or V6 gearbox in the TAR21 and normal parts, but it doesnt. I for one forgive them this decision and very well understand their decision to do what they did.

"If you wanna be different, get ready to do things different"

- BACK TO THE ACTUAL TOPIC FOR A CHANGE -

Am i seeing things or does the PDR have a "Long sylinder" ?

While it may add some semi-lag and reduce ROF, i'm actually hoping im right in this. I have such in my L85 and kinda like it. im not sure i'd have the same pre-arming of the spring like its done in the L85 but its pretty nice to upgrade the FPS in those. My old Systema M100 spring pumps out well more then the 100m/s and the slow ROF with the blowback is sweet music to my ears and pure fear in "theirs" ^^

If it were to have a "long sylinder" would that dissapoint some as its quite different from regular setup? Would you leave it as it is, or would go for a conversion like the L85s have aviable?

Edited by swatti, 27 July 2012 - 02:19 PM.

There's no bright light in end of the tunnel, just a long walk back to the off-game area...

#124 FireKnife

FireKnife

    Tap, rack, bang? The missus or your gun?

  • Forum Regular
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 8,491 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Aberdeen, not for long though.
  • Country:United Kingdom

Posted 27 July 2012 - 02:18 PM

So, short, runs on common mags, feels like a P90?

I am sold.

Electric.

I am now back on the market, someone else buy my interest :P

However i really can see it selling quite well inspite of this fact.

'FireKnife'

Edited by FireKnife, 27 July 2012 - 02:19 PM.

57 Pistols owned and still counting, hopefully more to come soon.
They are (best at the top working down): 2x TM Colt Mark IV Series 70 (they are mde of win), 2x TM Night Warrior Custom, TM Foliage Warrior, 4x TM 1911A1, 5x TM Detonics, 2x TM MEU, TM PX4, 4x KSC USPc, 4x TM P226, 3x TM M9, TM Glock 17,TM 5.1 Hi-Capa, KSC SP2022, 2x TK VP70M, 2x KSC USP .45, KWA USPCT, Army Detonics, KJ Glock 27, KSC SP2340, Maruzen PPK/s, Maruzen P99, KSC M8000, HFC M190, KJ P14-.45, KJ Ruger Mk.1, 2x KSC Glock 18c, HFC Desert Eagle, KJ M9 Vertec ABS,2x KSC Glock 26, ACM Beretta 1934, Marushin PPK SAS, Unknown M93R, WE 3.8 1911, 2x KWC Colt Python.

Got a TM pistol for sale in good condition and still stock plastic bodied? Give me a PM.

If you see a :P in my post don't take it seriously. ;)


#125 starburst

starburst

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 941 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 02:59 PM

I can imagine if it sells well enough it will beg for a GBB version, doing it as an AEG makes sence for PTS as they dont make their own GBB PMAGs (yet).

Will be interested in seeing one of these when they are released as I love my PTS Masada, will also be interesting to see how well these sell as the design has not yet made it into production Real Steel (I think I read somewhere it was shelved) but with it being featured in a game or two I can see it being a popular alternatlve to the P90. I loved the P90 I had apart from the magazine size, so if this is as comfortable to use as the P90 and gives good performance I can see myself easily being in the market for one.
Posted Image

#126 NeoVeNoM

NeoVeNoM

    Mokkori!!!

  • Forum Regular
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,856 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gangsters paradize, no really!
  • Country:Belgium

Posted 27 July 2012 - 03:29 PM

the New G36 jg costs about as much as the Ares. At least where I buy them. Don't know for others.

Hey, if you can do it, like I said before, that means anything in between those ROF and power levels would be build-able! :D

So in general ARES can be counted as having aftermarket support, or are you saying that their stock parts in your experience are easy to get?


Not necessarily.
Ok, after market support should be better, especially on accessories.
If you see their site it's mind blowing they don't sell anything in the big 3 HK shops. Or is it only for domestic use?
I don't know.

I take my time researching regarding parts, and some parts I just make myself based on the actual function on the part.

Regardless of what the PDR will be on the inside, players will still want to open it and fiddle with it.
Posted Image
Challenge everything!!

#127 intinerious

intinerious

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 908 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 03:38 PM

the New G36 jg costs about as much as the Ares. At least where I buy them. Don't know for others.

Not necessarily.
Ok, after market support should be better, especially on accessories.
If you see their site it's mind blowing they don't sell anything in the big 3 HK shops. Or is it only for domestic use?
I don't know.

I take my time researching regarding parts, and some parts I just make myself based on the actual function on the part.

Regardless of what the PDR will be on the inside, players will still want to open it and fiddle with it.


I see you're in Belgium, so perhaps it's a UMAREX thing? :P The Ares being around the same price as a JG. Cheapest Ares G36 I found on WGC is USD 204 and most expensive JG G36 I found was USD 141 :P

Don't think there's a 'domestic use' issue here with Ares parts, it's just hard to get a hold of from what I understand, but I won't go further, already derailing the thread as it is :P

#128 SOUTHPAWMIKE

SOUTHPAWMIKE

    Adv Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 72 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 05:45 PM

I know the old estimates for a release on this thing were June-July. That appears to not be the case. Anyone know anything about when these will hit the market?
Traipsing about the woods with a gun since '05.

#129 starburst

starburst

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 941 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 05:47 PM

Last estimated date was August some time I believe, this happened with the Masada where the release date was pushed back a few times.
Posted Image

#130 SOUTHPAWMIKE

SOUTHPAWMIKE

    Adv Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 72 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 05:58 PM

August is good. August is my birthday. Now I know what to get myself as a present.

Apologies for asking. I merely skimmed this thread, not wanting to get caught up in the ARES discussion.
Traipsing about the woods with a gun since '05.

#131 NeoVeNoM

NeoVeNoM

    Mokkori!!!

  • Forum Regular
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,856 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gangsters paradize, no really!
  • Country:Belgium

Posted 27 July 2012 - 11:17 PM

I see you're in Belgium, so perhaps it's a UMAREX thing? :P The Ares being around the same price as a JG. Cheapest Ares G36 I found on WGC is USD 204 and most expensive JG G36 I found was USD 141 :P

Don't think there's a 'domestic use' issue here with Ares parts, it's just hard to get a hold of from what I understand, but I won't go further, already derailing the thread as it is :P

bought mine at Ehobby more than a year ago under Ares brand. Altogether costed me 150€ including shipping and taxes. Umarex nowadays are S&T AEG's.
Friend of mine used to sell JG G36c for 80€ in his store a couple of years ago. other stores at that time asked 120-160€. Chinese is mostly ASG or Cybergun.

Prices vary heavily depending on where you buy from.
Even for high end AEG's.

So anyone know if there will be a DE version of this PDR?

Edited by NeoVeNoM, 27 July 2012 - 11:18 PM.

Posted Image
Challenge everything!!

#132 CKinnerley

CKinnerley

    Is it tea break yet?

  • Forum Regular
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3,535 posts

Posted 27 July 2012 - 11:39 PM

Nothing been announced thus far regards other colours.

To be honest, as with ACR and FPG, this seems like the ideal candidate for a paint job to me. Nice big flat surfaces, not too complicated in shape like an AR or AK; bit like a G36 or P90 in that respect.

SAC(T) Kinnerley - Somewhere Away from Combat (Tea drinking)
REMF Tacticool on FacebookYouTube & Twitter
REVIEWS FirstSpear's Strandhögg Plate Carrier FirstSpear 6/12 Pockets ESC Custom 1911 Builds PTS AAC M4-2000 Suppressor PIG Armour Kit Bag

ARTICLES Adaptable Solutions Sling


#133 intinerious

intinerious

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 908 posts

Posted 28 July 2012 - 07:08 AM

Friend of mine used to sell JG G36c for 80€ in his store a couple of years ago. other stores at that time asked 120-160€. Chinese is mostly ASG or Cybergun.


It's because of the stupid ASG/CyberGun charging extra on you guys :(

#134 talon_0315

talon_0315

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 300 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:San Francisco Bay Area, CA, USA
  • Country:United States

Posted 11 August 2012 - 01:15 AM

Magpul PTS put a picture up on its Facebook page (PTS by Magpul) about 16 hours ago with this photo and the comment "Watch Out! It's coming soon..."

#135 NeoVeNoM

NeoVeNoM

    Mokkori!!!

  • Forum Regular
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,856 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gangsters paradize, no really!
  • Country:Belgium

Posted 11 August 2012 - 08:42 AM

Posted Image
Posted Image
Challenge everything!!

#136 adas1223

adas1223

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 5 posts

Posted 11 August 2012 - 12:16 PM

omg... real 1911 vs PDR aeg! cmonnnnnnnn im torn

#137 DarkLite

DarkLite

    Yes, commander, my hat is large and my cloak is billowing.

  • Commercial User
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 10,203 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Hong Kong
  • Country:Hong Kong

Posted 11 August 2012 - 02:34 PM

I hope this thing can take 14mm barrel attachments.

But to be honest, even if it didn't I'd still probably get one.

Posted Image


#138 swatti

swatti

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 307 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Classified
  • Country:Finland

Posted 29 August 2012 - 08:49 AM

One more month near its end and no new news on the PDR...

...Do prove me wrong.
There's no bright light in end of the tunnel, just a long walk back to the off-game area...

#139 Ivan le Fou

Ivan le Fou

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 433 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:France
  • Country:France

Posted 29 August 2012 - 10:44 AM

Seems to be a good and cheaper alternative to the Kriss.


w40k%20player.jpg

Professionals have standards: be polite, be efficient and have a plan to kill everyone you meet.


#140 swatti

swatti

    Regular Poster

  • Regular Poster
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 307 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Classified
  • Country:Finland

Posted 29 August 2012 - 11:42 AM

Just need a release-date and imma belivah...
There's no bright light in end of the tunnel, just a long walk back to the off-game area...




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Site Meter